Top 5 Italian Restaurants in NYC

When you’re in the mood for a hearty meal and a glass of wine, there’s nothing that hits the spot like Italian restaurants in NYC. So, what’s on the menu today? Need some Italian restaurants for date night to impress an out-of-towner from Mount Vernon? Looking for a rustic pasta joint that’s well worth the trek up from New Rochelle? Take a look at some of the best spots that the city has to offer.

Nonna Dora’s Pasta Bar (Kips Bay)

Are you craving pasta like Grandma used to make? Then Nonna Dora’s Pasta Bar in Kips Bay has you covered! The fresh pasta is made by hand, thanks to Nonna Dora herself, and every dish could be considered the best NYC italian food around. Whether you’re in the mood for a rabbit ragu orecchiette or a toasted almond cavatelli, you could easily be satisfied with anything on the menu.

Torrisi Bar & Restaurant (Nolita)

Want an unforgettable Italian restaurant for date night? Or do you just want to experience one of thievery best Italian restaurants in NYC? No matter the reason, Torrisi Bar & Restaurant will provide you with the meal of a lifetime. This is an absolute institution among Italian food spots in Manhattan with decadence dishes like rotisserie lamb and duck alla mulberry, but Italian fusion options like cavatelli with Jamaican beef keeps the menu even more interesting.

Michael’s of Brooklyn (Brooklyn)

If you want to feel transported in time, Michael’s will take you back to its opening days of 1964. There’s a piano player filling the air with music, and the white tablecloths set the stage for amazing NYC Italian food. Treat yourself to the signature Veal Alla Michael in a white wine and shrimp sauce, or enjoy the tried-and-true Chicken Parmigiana – fried to perfection.

Ci Siamo (Hudson Yards)

There are countless Italian food spots in Manhattan, so what makes Ci Siamo stand out as one of the very best Italian food spots in Manhattan? It’s all about refinement. This restaurant spares no expense at making patrons from Westchester to Bronx feel like royalty, including opulent decor and live-fire cooking. The caramelized onion torta is a fan favorite, and you can’t go wrong with the wood-fired trout or braised lamp. Don’t forget to save room for gelati!

Misi (Williamsburg)

Misi is a pasta lover’s dream, and it’s some of the best NYC Italian food around. The menu is focused on fresh, bold flavors with a distinctive rustic twist. Try the buffalo butter fettuccine or 30-clove pomodoro rigatoni for updated classics, and don’t miss out on their extensive wine menu during your next Italian restaurant date night.

Learn More about NYC Italian Food with Victory Mitsubishi

We’ve gone through the top five best Italian restaurants in NYC, but what if you crave more? The team at Victory Mitsubishi is no stranger to phenomenal NYC Italian food, and we’d love to help you get to your next date night in style. Visit us in Bronx for all of your automotive needs, from trade-ins to maintenance, and contact us with any questions about the area! We’d be happy to help you find anything from the best restaurants in Yonkers to the best pizza in the Bronx!